NHS bosses oppose election plan

Article Source: Health And Fitness Journal

By Andrew Black
Political reporter, BBC Scotland news website

What does your NHS board think about direct elections
Most of Scotland’s NHS authorities are either opposed to or have serious concern about plans for direct elections to their health boards.

Some health bosses have raised concern that the proposals could destabilise boards by pulling them into party politics.

Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon told BBC Scotland the concerns were not well-founded.

She also insisted the scheme was “massively popular”.

Direct health board elections, a key SNP election manifesto pledge, was brought forward by the party in government to improve public confidence in the health system.

Ministers have cited concern that health authorities had not always properly listened to local views, but several NHS boards disagreed.

It has emerged that five of Scotland’s 14 health authorities – Highland, Tayside, Ayrshire and Arran, Lothian and Grampian – have opposed direct health board elections outright.

"Any institution facing a quite radical change might be resistant to that change"
Nicola Sturgeon
Scottish health secretary

A further five – Shetland, Forth Valley, Lanarkshire, Greater Glasgow and Orkney – have expressed doubts about the plans.

They include concerns about the “politicisation” of boards and being flooded with single-issue candidates with no interest in overall policy.

Critics also pointed out that councillors already sat on health boards, which were accountable to ministers and parliament.

But Ms Sturgeon said ordinary people should be given a say in the running of the health service which they paid for, adding: “It’s also massively popular and I think it’s the right thing to do.”

She went on: “I don’t think democracy is ever a bad thing.

“I understand and am aware of some of the concerns health boards have. I don’t agree that those concerns are well-founded.”

The Scottish Government hopes to pilot direct health board elections, probably with two NHS authorities, in a Bill currently going through parliament.

Test concerns

However, opposition parties are sceptical towards the plan, and could vote the legislation down.

One NHS board – Fife – backed the bill, while NHS Western Isles said it had not discussed the plans and Dumfries and Galloway declined to comment until after the pilot.

Ms Sturgeon said she was not surprised by the health boards’ reservations, but said she was confident they would eventually come round.

“Any institution facing a quite radical change might be resistant to that change, but what convinces me this is the right thing to do is that the public think it’s right and I believe it’s right, because the NHS is a public service and it’s right that it should be influenced in terms of what the public think.”

The health secretary added: “In any event, if the bill passes, we will have pilot elections to test out some of these concerns in practice and then parliament would have to decide before health board elections could be rolled out further.”

One of the earliest acts of the SNP in government was to reverse decisions by the previous administration to close accident and emergency units at Ayr hospital and Monklands in Lanarkshire, which had caused a local outcry.



“NHS Borders operates within the context of governmental policy and, therefore, comments submitted following the call for written evidence did not represent the views of our board, but reflected the opinions of a number of individuals.”


“Although there is a spectrum of views across NHS Highland board members, overall we are strongly opposed to the principle of direct elections. The majority view of NHS Highland is that the existing arrangements for the appointment of public members to NHS boards work well.”


“NHS Orkney sees no benefits in having additional elected members on its board under the system highlighted in the Bill. In small, rural areas there is a real risk that those who are elected are members of groups with particular issues, rather than having the wider interest across the whole range of health board priorities.”


“We believe we can demonstrate delivery of robust internal accountability through our current non-executive members. We suspect that further, wholesale change to the current system has the potential to destabilise boards.”


“NHS Dumfries and Galloway understands that the proposals under the Health Boards (Membership and Elections) Bill are to be piloted elsewhere in Scotland. Until the outcome of the pilot arrangements have been made known and our board has the opportunity to consider its position, NHS Dumfries and Galloway has no other comment.”


“Ministers have set out the policy directions and NHS Fife fully supports their Bill. When the government was considering policy earlier this year via a consultation document, NHS Fife expressed agreement with the starting premise that the public does not believe NHS boards have taken sufficient account of the views of local people.”


“Tayside NHS Board does not believe that the limited attempt to democratise health boards by electing some members to boards will do much to enhance the concept of mutuality. For the board, mutuality emphasises participation much more than representation.”


“NHS Ayrshire and Arran would not support the introduction of this Bill. It would change and confuse, rather than increase, accountability, it would be likely to undermine the operation of a national NHS [and] there is no evidence that it would increase the quality of decision-making.”


“The current local authority membership of both NHS boards and Community Health Partnerships provides a significant, democratic input to the working of these bodies. To expand directly elected health board members as proposed in the Bill would only lead to confusion and conflict between members from different ‘electoral’ systems.”


“Elected members are unlikely to have the mechanisms in place to enable them to seek the views of the electorate and, therefore, would be elected on the basis of their manifesto. It would be difficult, therefore, for them to truly represent the local population and the risk to boards is that their input is based on particular issues and a lack of understanding about the broader health board issues.”


“There are already a substantial number of mechanisms in health and in local authorities, and through health and local authority partnership arrangements, for the needs and views of local communities to be heard effectively.”


“There could be possible tensions between locally elected council members on NHS boards and those appointed through the direct elections process and tensions between non-executive members appointed through an open and competitive process and, again, the members appointed by the direct election process.”


“The matter of direct elections to health boards has not been discussed by Western Isles Health Board.”


“The board would strongly object to diverting current resources from patients to support elections, but the cheapest method must be adopted, and the cost met nationally without detriment to patient services, either in money or staff time.”Return to top

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation

Other Related Health Posts:

Buy and Sell text links

Article Source: Health And Fitness Journal
If you like all this stuff here then you can buy me a pack of cigarettes.

Comments Off on NHS bosses oppose election plan.

Primary teacher in cancer appeal

Article Source: Health And Fitness Journal

An appeal has been launched to raise £130,000 to send a primary school teacher to America for potentially life-saving brain tumour treatment.

Melissa Huggins, 27, of Staines, south-west London, is battling a cancerous brain tumour for the second time.

Doctors have told Miss Huggins her tumour is inoperable and a form of treatment not available in Britain is her best hope of survival.

Miss Huggins’ fiance, family and friends have raised £20,000 so far.

Melissa’s Fighting Fund is hosting a range of events and hopes to have enough money in place to allow Miss Huggins to travel to Boston General hospital early in the new year for treatment.

Wedding postponed

Miss Huggins, who teaches at St Ignatius Primary School in Sunbury, discovered during regular screening in late October that her cancer had returned.

"It really humbles you that so many people care so much"
Melissa Huggins

But she said she remains upbeat and grateful for the support she has received.

“It really humbles you that so many people care so much,” she said.

Miss Huggins said she and her fiance had postponed their wedding planned for next year and put the money they would have spent on that towards the treatment.

“I cannot ask anyone else for money if I wasn’t willing to make my own sacrifices,” she said.

Miss Huggins said her campaign was not just about saving her own life but about raising awareness of the need for health officials in the UK to purchase the specialised equipment needed.

“It’s about trying to get a proton machine in this country because it could save so many lives,” she said.

Targeted treatment

The treatment would use highly-targeted protons rather than traditional radiotherapy to kill cancer cells growing in the tumour near the base of her brain stem.

The only machine in Britain that delivers the therapy is a low-energy variety used to treat eye cancers. It is not powerful enough to be used on other cancers.

The proton therapy is deemed more effective because it only targets cancer cells and does not damage healthy tissue surrounding the tumour.

The NHS estimates that creating a fully-equipped proton therapy centre in Britain would cost between £50-100m

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation

Other Related Health Posts:

Buy and Sell text links

Article Source: Health And Fitness Journal
If you like all this stuff here then you can buy me a pack of cigarettes.

Comments Off on Primary teacher in cancer appeal.

UN warns of Zimbabwe cholera jump

Article Source: Health And Fitness Journal

The UN Children’s Fund in Zimbabwe says it is preparing to deal with a possible 60,000 cholera cases in coming weeks, four times current official estimates.

The Unicef chief in Harare, Roeland Monasch, said such a jump could bring the number of deaths to around 3,000.

Official figures say nearly 600 have already died from the disease but aid agencies fear the toll could be higher.

UK PM Gordon Brown says it is an international crisis and the world must tell Robert Mugabe “enough is enough”.

Mr Monasch told the BBC that they were doing all they could to bring mortality rates down.

But he warned that if as many as 60,000 people became infected in the next few weeks, then the cholera epidemic could kill another 2,700.See detailed map of cholera affected areas

He says the actual number of people who have already died is probably far higher than official figures as many clinics and hospitals are closed and people in rural areas frequently just bury their dead.

"Children in Zimbabwe are on the brink, and everyone’s focus must now be on their survival"
Roeland Monasch

Unicef’s Zimbabwe Communication Officer Tsitsi Singizi said local authorities did not have the capacity to provide safe water and rubbish collection. Cholera is often linked to contaminated supplies of drinking water.

Tsitsi Singizi said health services had also collapsed, making it impossible to treat the high number of infections.

“The outbreak is really outpacing our response. It’s becoming endemic. Nine out of 10 provinces have reported a cholera case.”

Unicef has launched an emergency response programme to focus on providing basic services – increasing health outreach services, providing nutritional supplements, boosting school attendance, and increasing access to safe water in the short term.

“Children in Zimbabwe are on the brink, and everyone’s focus must now be on their survival,” said Mr Monasch.

The disease has spread to neighbouring South Africa, Mozambique, Zambia and Botswana.


The situation has forced President Mugabe’s government to declare a national emergency and appeal for international assistance.

But it has also drawn increasing international condemnation of Mr Mugabe, including calls from key African figures for military force to oust him.

Mr Mugabe and opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai agreed to share power in September to tackle the country’s economic meltdown but they have been unable to agree on the allocation of cabinet posts.

The deadlocked agreement followed disputed elections, which both men claimed to have won.

In the UK, the Archbishop of York Dr John Sentamu joined in criticism of Zimbabwe’s government and called for Mr Mugabe and his allies to be overthrown so they can stand trial in The Hague.

Return to top

Are you in Zimbabwe Do you live in a neighbouring country Have you been affected by cholera Send us your comments by completing the form below.

In most cases a selection of your comments will be published, displaying your name and location unless you state otherwise in the box below.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation

Other Related Health Posts:

Buy and Sell text links

Article Source: Health And Fitness Journal
If you like all this stuff here then you can buy me a pack of cigarettes.

Comments Off on UN warns of Zimbabwe cholera jump.